The Buddha and Dr. Fuhrer

An Archaeological Scandal
By Charles Allen

In January 1898 a British landowner, William Claxton Pepp?, excavated a large Buddhist brick stupa on his estate close to India’s border to Nepal. At a depth of 24 feet he uncovered a huge stone coffer, within which were a number of reliquary vases together with a mass of jewels and gold offerings. The opening of the Piprahwa stupa followed on from the discovery nearby of the birthplace of the Buddha (Lumbini) and the legendary city (Kapilavastu) where he had grown into manhood as Prince Sidhartha, but what made this discovery so important was an inscription found on the top of one of the reliquary caskets – declaring it to contain ashes of the Buddha left there by members of his own Sakya clan. This news aroused world-wide interest, not least in the Buddhist World, since no other so well authenticated relics of the Buddha had ever been found. But almost immediately it became known that a German archaeologist, Dr Anton F?hrer, working nearby at the same time had not only made bogus claims and faked his results but had also been associated with the dig. F?hrer was quickly unmasked by a British magistrate who himself had a stake in the excavation.  




'In this dense and quirky volume, Charles Allen unravels the saga of the discovery, a twisted tale of truth and lies that has divided Buddhist scholars for a century. He begins, quite properly, byreconstructing the forested Tarai landscape of the fifth century BC inwhich the Buddha grew up, material he touched on in his 2002 volume TheBuddha and the Sahibs... Allen displays a strong sense of narrative,conjuring shikaris bent over trenches in their enormous solar topees while a naked sadhu from the local temple looks on from the shade of a banyan tree, no doubt thinking all foreigners insane... Allen is adistinguished author in the field... In these pages he pieces the story together like the shards of a broken vase while avoiding the F?hrertendency to reach hasty conclusions. '

Sara Wheeler, The SundayTelegraph.
To read the whole review click here


 
Renowned India expert Charles Allen tells the story, weaving in theresults of a conference held at Harewood House in June 2006 on the validity of the Piprahwa dig and considering the results of recent carbon dating.
Born in Cawnpore in the last years of the British Raj, Charles Allen’s family’s association with India dates back on the battle Seringapatam in 1799. His great-grandfather brought the young Rudyard Kipling out to work on his newspaper, the Civil Military Gazette. Mr Allen is a traveller, writer and broadcaster, specialising in India and the Far East. He is the author of Plain Tales of the Raj and most recently a critical biography of Kipling.