Chaim Weizmann: The Zionist Dream

Makers of the Modern World: The peace conferences of 1919-23 and their aftermath
By Tom Fraser

Quantity:

The Arab-Israeli conflict has been one of the most defining features of recent world history, flaring up into open war fare yet again in Gaza at the end of 2008 and provoking large-scale demonstrations in the streets of cities across the world.

The decision in 1919 by the Paris Peace Conference to award the Mandate for Palestine to Great Britain – which had announced its commitment to the creation of a national home for the Jewish people in the Balfour Declaration two years previously – sowed the seeds of this seemingly intractable problem, yet when the Zionist leader Chaim Weizmann (1874–1952) spoke before the Conference on 27 February 1919, he would have appeared as only one of the many representatives of minor nationalities putting their case to the peacemakers, and, what is more, one whose people had no territory of their own. How a Jewish chemistry professor from an obscure part of Eastern Europe could find himself at the heart of international diplomacy, and later become the first president of the State of Israel, is one of the most fascinating stories of the Paris Peace Conference and its aftermath.

Ninety years after the Conference, what Weizmann said and did there is an essential part of our understanding of how this small, but critical, part of the world evolved out of the deliberations.

T G Fraser MBE is Professor Emeritus of History and Honorary Professor of Conflict Research at the University of Ulster. His other books include: Partition in Ireland, India and Palestine: Theory and practice (1984); The USA and the Middle East since World War II (1989); and The Arab-Israeli Conflict (1995). He has edited, or jointly edited,five books, including The Middle East1914-1979 (1980).

---

As featured on RTE Radio 1 - 'Today with Pat Kenny' on Friday 23rd April 2o10:

San Remo Anniversary

'The Italian resort city of San Remo is perhaps more associated with the holidaymakers and highrollers who visit its beaches and casinos than with international diplomacy. Nonetheless in April 1920, Allied leaders including the Prime Ministers of Britain, France and Italy chose this setting for the international conference that was to decide the future shape of the Middle East and we are still feeling the effects of it internationally today.

Two books are published on Monday, the 90th anniversary of that fateful conference looking at the outcome from very different perspectives. Under the subtitles, The Dream of Arabia and The Zionist Dream Robert McNamara and T G Fraser, examine the outcome from the Paris Peace Treaties following the First World War as part of the Makers of the Modern World series from Haus Publishing, London.

The series looks at the issues from the point of view of the leaders around the table. For Arabs, The Dream of Arabia was in the hands of Prince Feisal. For Jews seeking a homeland The Zionist Dream was in the hands of Chaim Weizmann.

Pat was joined from our Belfast studio by Robert MacNamara, lecturer in International History at the University of Ulster, Coleraine and and on the line by Tom Fraser, Professor Emeritus of History and Honorary Professor of Conflict research at the University of Ulster.'

---

Article in the Jewish News by author Tom Fraser, April 2010

To understand the Middle East we must return to San Remo

'For Zionists, the decisions taken at San Remo 90 years ago were just as important as the Blafour Declaration'

---

Review from the H-Diplo Review Project, America

'Zionism has been an amazingly successful enterprise. The notion of building a national movement for a widely dispersed partly assimilated people and of implementing this movement's vision by actually building a national state could easily be dismissed as a fantasy, as it often was. Zionism's success was facilitated by extraneous circumstances – the holocaust, the weakness and errors of its Arab antagonists, by its own innate strength and, to a large extent, by the quality of its leadership, from the original visionary, Theodor Herzl, to Israel's founding fathers, Chaim Weizmann and David Ben-Gurion. Ben-Gurion was the leader who led the Zionist movement and the Jewish community in Palestine through the final phases of the struggle for statehood and was subsequently the first prime minister who left an indelible imprint on the young Israeli state.

Chaim Weizmann, who preceded Ben-Gurion as the leader of the Zionist movement, lost the primacy to the dominant figure in the Jewish community in Palestine. He was elected as Israel's first president and head of state, but never concealed his bitterness for having to settle on a ceremonial role.

Weizmann's position declined when the center of gravity shifted from the Diaspora to the growing community in Palestine and from London to Washington. Weizmann's heyday as Zionism's leader coincided with his 'British period' and with Britain 'moment' in the Middle East, when it became the paramount power in the Middle East, assumed control of Palestine and undertook to build a Jewish 'national home' in the territory assigned to it as League of Nations mandate.

Weizmann played a major role in these events. Britain's decision to take control of Palestine (contrary to its undertakings to its French and Arab allies) and to establish a Jewish national home there was motivated by complex considerations – from a desire to have a land bridge from Iraq to the Mediterranean, through the reluctance to have French presence so close to the Suez Cannel, to the expectations that Jewish influence in the United States and Soviet Russia would be directed to support the war. There were also countervailing considerations and the British government's decision to issue the Balfour Declaration in November 1917 and to convert it into a Palestine Mandate could not be envisaged without the role played by Chaim Weizmann.

T.G. Fraser was commissioned to write the volume on Weizmann in the series 'Makers of the Modern World' which deals with 'the peace conferences of 1919-1923 and their aftermath'. He thus had the pleasant task of dealing with Weizmann's heyday. The volumes in this series are slim and the series is designed for the educated lay leader. Prof. Fraser has ably captured Weizmann's chrisma and charm and his ability to manipulate and influence the British ruling elite. He is also skillful in taking the reader through the maze of World War I diplomacy and its aftermath. The book is not meant to engage the academic community and is not free of inaccuracies (due largely to over-reliance on Weizmann's own writings), but as a brief engaging account of Weizmann the leader and the origins of the Jewish national home, it is an excellent piece of work.' - Itamar Rabinovich,

 Tel Aviv University and NYU.   

---

Review from Itamar Rabinovich, Tel Aviv University and NYU.